My Dad started watching Wednesday in the mid-30's; I started in 1962 and my uncle joined us a year or two later. I didn't understand all the goings on at the club at the time and of course there was no social media but Dad always said Catterick was far and away our best manager. But there was always a fear his ambition would be too much and so it proved. He'd spent many years at Everton as a player, albeit mostly in the reserves, and the pools money of the Moores family meant when they sacked their manager at the back end of 1960/61 his departure was inevitable.
The comment about Joe Baker is right; Catterick always said that if he'd come to us we would have won the league that year but the Board said no. The supreme irony in all this is that twice in the following years we broke the British transfer record for a teenager. But in 1969, when we bought Tommy Craig, the ship had well and truly sailed.
Dad thought Vic Buckingham was an odd choice as Catterick's replacement being totally his opposite. His pre-match team talk was apparently always along the lines of "well, how should we play it today" as he liked his players to express their own individuality. But his time co-incided with the Bribes Scandal and Eric Taylor, for one, blamed this to a large extent on the lax attitude Buckingham brought. Alan Brown was an obvious choice as replacement; a former coach at Hillsborough in the 1950's he had sorted Sunderland out after their own scandals. He was what you would call a "tough disciplinarian" but scrupulously honest in all his dealings. And he was well respected as a manager with many of his players, the likes of Don Megson, Ian Branfoot and Sam Ellis who all went into management, keeping in touch with him for advice for years afterwards. But he was very limited in his style and once the post-Cup Final vibe had worn off he seemed unable to reset the club again. After that, well, the rot well and truly set in.
Dad always said the post-Catterick years were ones of missed opportunity. We had a solid side but missed that streak of individuality that top players bring. In short, we seemed happy where we were at a time when the playing field was so much more level than today. If Catterick had stayed and been given the support who knows but my guess is we'd be a far different club today.